Democrats Have One Clear Shot to Take Back the Judiciary

Politics

/
February 1, 2024

Democrats Have One Clear Shot to Take Back the Judiciary

To counter the damage Trump did to the judiciary by stuffing it with conservative judges, Biden & Co need to act fast. Right now, they’re not.

Elie Mystal

Ad Policy

Five of President Joe Biden’s nominees to the federal judiciary are sworn in during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on Wednesday, Oct. 4, 2023.

(Eric Lee / Bloomberg via Getty Images)

By any objective measure, President Joe Biden has been incredibly successful with his judicial nominations. He appointed a record number of judges in his first year in office, and 88 percent of his nominees have been confirmed by the Senate—no small feat given the Democrats’ slim majority in that body (thank you, Vice-President Kamala Harris). And Biden’s nominees have been incredibly diverse in terms of gender, ethnicity, and experience. 

Unfortunately, Biden cannot be judged by an objective measure. His appointments must be viewed in the context of his immediate predecessor, Donald Trump, and Trump’s makeover of the federal judiciary in the Federalist Society’s image.

By that measure, Biden is not doing all he needs to do. According to the Brookings Institute, Trump appointed a record-setting 177 district court judges, 53 circuit court judges, and three Supreme Court judges in his four years. Biden has  appointed only 126 district court judges, 39 circuit court judges, and one Supreme Court justice in his first three years. Biden still has time to make up the gap, but he is already behind Trump’s three-year output, and the fourth year is when Trump got serious about remaking the courts. It’s important to remember that in 2020, Trump’s last year in office, he and Mitch McConnell turned the Senate into a judicial-confirmation machine. 

Thus far, the same cannot be said of Biden or Senate Judiciary Chairman Dick Durbin. As of this writing, there are 59 open seats throughout the federal judiciary. Biden has made nominations for only 22 of those seats, and many of those 22 are withering on the vine in Durbin’s committee. 

Establishment Democrats and Durbin defenders blame Republicans. A couple of months ago, the Republicans on the Judiciary Committee threw an epic hissy fit when Democrats subpoenaed Federalist Society svengali Leonard Leo and conservative judicial sugar daddy Harlan Crow to appear before the committee in an ethics probe. Since then, Republicans have been using every possible procedural trick to slow the confirmation process. 

But the larger problem is Durbin’s insistence on honoring what is known as the “blue slip” process for judicial nominations. The blue slip allows senators to weigh in on a president’s judicial nominee from their state, and to do so before the nomination is made to the wider body. Traditionally, if a senator approves of the nominee, they will return a “blue slip” and the confirmation process can go forward; If the senator disapproves, the president finds a more agreeable nominee. It’s one of the reasons “red states” end up with conservative federal courts, while “blue states” end up with liberal ones.

Current Issue


January 2024 Issue

Like the filibuster, the blue slip is not a constitutional rule or a federal statute, it’s just another anachronistic, anti-democratic tradition maintained by the broken Senate. And, like the filibuster, former Senate Majority Leader McConnell simply ignored it when it stood between Republicans and judicial power. McConnell and Trump didn’t let the lack of blue slips stop them from appointing hyper-conservative judges to the Second Circuit (which covers New York), Ninth Circuit (which covers California and most of the West), or, critically, the DC Circuit (which is important because hears most cases involving regulations made by federal agencies and, you know, decides whether presidents are immune from criminal prosecution). 

Durbin has brought them back, and the Biden administration is honoring them. Of the current vacancies in the judiciary, 33 are in states with at least one Republican senator. Only 19 percent of Biden’s judges thus far have been sent to states with one Republican senator. By contrast, 51 percent of Trump’s nominees went to a state with at least one Democratic senator. 

It’s like Biden and Durbin are trying to chase down the people who have kidnapped the federal judiciary, but they won’t drive over 55 mph because they’re worried about violating the speed limit. There’s no mystery as to why they’re falling behind. They’re adhering to rules the other side won’t follow. It’s, frankly, pathetic. 

Biden and Durbin won’t force judges into Republican-controlled enclaves, and they can’t run up the score in Democratic states because—and I can’t believe I have to type this—old ass liberal judges won’t retire and let Biden appoint their lifetime replacement while he still can. Of the 17 circuit court judges appointed by Barack Obama or Bill Clinton who became eligible in the last year for “senior status” (a semi-retirement that allows judges to vacate their seat but still draw their full salary and work on cases), only three relinquished their power and allowed Biden to replace them. Three, y’all. Only three of these people were able to look at the 2024 Senate electoral map, and an actuarial table, and piece together the information wisely. Excuse me while I say “Ruth Bader Ginsburg” in my bathroom mirror three times and wait for the sweet release of death. 

I do not know what to say to Biden, Durbin, 14 judges appointed by Democratic presidents, and the wider liberal intelligentsia to make them take the courts more seriously. Republicans are ruthless when it comes to judicial appointments, confirmations, and retirements. Their rewards have been a judiciary that takes away abortion rights, allows polluters to befoul the earth, destroys organized labor, menaces transgender kids, commandeers federal immigration policy, and makes it easy for mass shooters to accumulate weapons. 

Democrats lose on all of these issues, despite having policies with broad, popular appeal, because Democrats have lost control of the courts. We are mere months away from a potential re-ordering of political power in this country, and we have the opportunity to appoint people who are immune to such political headwinds and can hold power for literal decades, yet Biden is waiting for senators like Ted Cruz and Tommy Tuberville to return a slip of paper that approves his use of the constitutional power to appoint judges. 

It is maddening. It is malpractice. And yet it is the modus operandi of the Democratic party during my lifetime. This right here is why we fail.

Keep Reading

Elie Mystal

Elie Mystal is The Nation’s justice correspondent and the host of its legal podcast, Contempt of Court. He is also an Alfred Knobler Fellow at the Type Media Center. His first book is the New York Times bestseller Allow Me to Retort: A Black Guy’s Guide to the Constitution, published by The New Press. Elie can be followed @ElieNYC.

More from The Nation

Israel Is Using Bush’s War on Terror Playbook

Israel Is Using Bush’s War on Terror Playbook

Israel has given itself license for unfettered state violence under the guise of an unprecedented existential threat. Sound familiar?

Maha Hilal

Taylor Swift, Enemy of the People

Taylor Swift, Enemy of the People

The MAGA movement—including the big man himself—has gone on the offensive against the megastar pop singer.

Chris Lehmann

What if This Were the Headline?

What if This Were the Headline?

How might our reaction change?

How AI Is Transforming the Way Political Campaigns Work

How AI Is Transforming the Way Political Campaigns Work

The future is arriving—and we’d better watch out.

Micah L. Sifry

Calling for Respect, Freedom, and Security for All Is Not Antisemitic

Calling for Respect, Freedom, and Security for All Is Not Antisemitic

My obligation to critique the Israeli state comes from my own Jewish tradition, a tradition which had to defend itself from genuine antisemitism.

Marshall Ganz

The Absolute Clarity of Barbara Lee’s Senate Bid

The Absolute Clarity of Barbara Lee’s Senate Bid

On matters of war and peace, the representative is prepared to tell presidents that they must follow the Constitution—even Democratic presidents.

John Nichols