/
October 5, 2023
The “Trump for Speaker” Campaign Shipwrecks on the Shoals of Stupidity
Some House Republicans want the former president to be their new boss. There are just two problems with this plan: it’s crazy, and it’s not allowed.
(Fox News / YouTube)
Kevin McCarthy’s speakership ended as it began—in chaos. Unprepared to build coalitions, unwilling to stand firm against the crazies in his own caucus, and, ultimately, unable to count votes at the moment when vote counting mattered most, the California Republican was deposed on Tuesday amid a cacophony of threats, insults, accusations and whining.
So how did House Republicans propose to address the most serious leadership crisis they have experienced since their ill-thought attempt to remove Bill Clinton blew up a quarter century ago on scandal-plagued House Speaker Newt Gingrich and his hapless successor, adulterous Louisiana Republican Robert Livingston?
As of Thursday morning, two people—House Majority Leader Steve Scalise and House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan—have declared their candidacy for the speakership. But some House Republicans are pushing an even more chaotic prospect: Speaker of the House Donald Trump.
Within hours of the House’s 216-210 vote to vacate McCarthy’s speakership, Texas Republican Troy Nehls declared, “This week, when the US House of Representatives reconvenes, my first order of business will be to nominate Donald J Trump for speaker of the US House of Representatives. President Trump, the greatest president of my lifetime, has a proven record of putting America first and will make the House great again.”
Even by the unusually high levels of political obsequiousness that are observed when Republican members of Congress start talking about Trump, Nehls’s announcement stood out by blending desperate hints of tragedy and farce. So, of course, Georgia Republican Marjorie Taylor Greene decided to outdo him, posting a picture on Wednesday of Trump wearing an outsized “Make America Great Again” cap and wielding the House gavel. “This is my choice for Speaker of the House!” announced Greene.
Other House Republicans jumped into the “Trump for Speaker” clown car, and by Tuesday night, Fox News host Sean Hannity was reporting, “Sources telling me at this hour some House Republicans have been in contact with and have started an effort to draft former President Donald Trump to be the next Speaker, and I have been told that President Trump might be open to helping the Republican Party, at least in the short term, if necessary.”
Trump dubbed the prospect “interesting.”
“Lots of people have been calling me about Speaker, all I can say is we’ll do whatever is best for the country and for the Republican Party,” Trump said Wednesday morning. Pressed to clarify whether he might actually serve as speaker for the remainder of the 118th Congress, Trump said he was “totally focused” on his 2024 presidential bid. But then he added, “If I can help them during the process, I’ll do it.”
Current Issue
Was Trump saying he’d take a temporary speakership? Maybe. Maybe not.
It didn’t matter to Republican presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy. Somewhere in the word salad that was served up by the former president, Ramaswamy—who has urged House Republicans to ask themselves, “Is chaos really such a bad thing?—heard what he wanted to hear. Of the prospect that Trump might be given the gavel and control of the House, Ramaswamy declared on Wednesday, “This isn’t crazy. We need to shake things up in there.”
Actually, it is crazy, for a variety of reasons. But one reason is particularly worthy of consideration.
While it’s true that someone who is not a member of the House can serve as speaker, Trump is currently barred from holding the position. Who says? The House Republican Conference.
According to the Conference Rules of the 118th Congress, “If a member of Elected Republican Leadership… publicly announces his or her intention to seek other elected office in Federal, state, or local government, that Member shall resign from such leadership position.”
Trump is an announced presidential candidate. So he is precluded by his own party’s rule from serving as speaker.
Popular
“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →
The Reason Gavin Newsom Didn’t Appoint Barbara Lee Is the Reason She Should Be a Senator
The Reason Gavin Newsom Didn’t Appoint Barbara Lee Is the Reason She Should Be a Senator
How DeSantis Is Using Sports to Hijack a Florida College
How DeSantis Is Using Sports to Hijack a Florida College
Lawmakers May Finally Update Strict SSI Rules That Keep Families in Poverty
Lawmakers May Finally Update Strict SSI Rules That Keep Families in Poverty
We Are Witnessing the First Stages of Civilization’s Collapse
We Are Witnessing the First Stages of Civilization’s Collapse
But that’s not the only barrier. The caucus rules also state that: “A member of the Republican Leadership shall step aside if indicted for a felony for which a sentence of two or more years imprisonment may be imposed.”
Trump faces 91 indictments, the vast majority of which check the “two or more years imprisonment” box.
So Trump isn’t just blocked from assuming the speakership—he’s doubly blocked.
The fact that a cabal of GOP representatives was so eager to pay homage to the former president that they didn’t even bother to check their own rules won’t shock regular observers of the Republican-controlled House. But it does provide a sobering reminder of the extent to which elected Republicans have sacrificed their own judgment to the cult of Trumpism.
Don’t be surprised if there are proposals to rewrite the rules. It wouldn’t be the first time that the Republicans have gone to extreme lengths to accommodate Trump. This is, after all, the party that failed to adopt a 2020 platform because the former president didn’t want one.
Anyone in their right mind will tell you that abandoning Republican rules that bar indicted Republicans from serving in House leadership in order to clear hurdles for a prospective Speaker who faces charges in multiple jurisdictions crosses the line even for a Trumped-up GOP.
Then again, there is plentiful evidence to suggest that House Republicans are not currently in their right mind.
John Nichols
John Nichols is a national affairs correspondent for The Nation. He has written, cowritten, or edited over a dozen books on topics ranging from histories of American socialism and the Democratic Party to analyses of US and global media systems. His latest, cowritten with Senator Bernie Sanders, is the New York Times bestseller It’s OK to Be Angry About Capitalism.
More from The Nation
Hope for Asylum Seekers
Hope for Asylum Seekers
The Biden administration will allow nearly half a million Venezuelan migrants in the United States to live and work legally in the country for 18 months.
Who Is the Real Laphonza Butler?
Who Is the Real Laphonza Butler?
The new senator from California has been both a union organizer and a corporate consultant. Which side of her will we see in Congress?
Progressive Democrats in Congress Have Had Our Backs. Now We Need to Have Theirs.
Progressive Democrats in Congress Have Had Our Backs. Now We Need to Have Theirs.
One of our biggest jobs in 2024 is to protect our progressive champions from the array of right-wing forces trying to remove them from office.
The Reason Gavin Newsom Didn’t Appoint Barbara Lee Is the Reason She Should Be a Senator
The Reason Gavin Newsom Didn’t Appoint Barbara Lee Is the Reason She Should Be a Senator
Lee called out the California governor’s approach to filling the vacancy, maintaining her tradition of speaking truth to power. Newsom wasn’t impressed. But voters should be.
Kevin McCarthy Is History
Kevin McCarthy Is History
The Republican speaker of the House has become the first ever to be ousted from his position.
Donald Trump’s Latest Threats Really Are About the Violence
Donald Trump’s Latest Threats Really Are About the Violence
It can be tempting to dismiss Trump’s threats against his perceived opponents as mere bluster, but his attacks on Letitia James make it clear that he’s not just playing around.
Latest from the nation
Today 11:21 am
The Vanguard Party of the Christian Right
Today 8:30 am
Hope for Asylum Seekers
Today 5:00 am
